The Old Newspaper is a memo in Silent Hill: Homecoming found on the park bench in Shepherd's Glen and also in the reception room of the Toluca Lake Offices in Silent Hill. The newspaper clipping details a story of a murderer, whose actions seem eerily similar to Walter Sullivan's. Prior to examining this newspaper, children can be heard singing, "We all fall down!", which are the ending lines to the popular childhood song "Ring Around the Rosies," which is actually and, quite disturbingly, about the Bubonic Plague.
- Paul Russell Douglas was executed for the murder of 8 children in and around Silent Hill and Shepherd's Glen areas, according to court records. He offered no resistance as he was arrested and strapped into the electric chair as officials, witnesses and reporters watched.
- "This execution is not going to stop anything." Douglas said. "I've worked and waited for this day. All that's left is to rejoin my lord."
- After preparations were completed, Douglas received a sudden blast of electrical current, followed by a two minute stream that jolted him back in the chair. Medical officials pronounced him dead at 2:09pm.