Nathan Drugs is located beneath the apartment of Dahlia and Alessa Gillespie. Rose Da Silva passes it three times in the film, twice after meeting Dahlia, which means her daughter Sharon may be inside the last two times. Several cultists, along with Christabella, deduce that Dahlia has helped Sharon to hide in their old apartment, and capture Sharon and Dahlia, before taking them to the church. They intend for Sharon to be burned alive as a witch and for Dahlia to "bear witness" to the execution.
|Rose Da Silva - Christopher Da Silva - Cybil Bennett - Dahlia Gillespie - Thomas Gucci - Anna - Christabella - Sharon Da Silva - Alessa Gillespie - Dark Alessa|
|Sister Margaret - Eleanor - Colin - Lisa Garland - Jennifer Carroll|
|Armless Man - Colin - Creeper - Dark Nurse - Grey Child - Red Pyramid|
|Brahms - Brookhaven Hospital - Church - Da Silva House - Gans County - Grand Hotel - Midwich Elementary School - Nathan Drugs - Pete's Bowl-O-Rama - Sacrificial Chamber - Silent Hill, West Virginia - Smitty's - Toluca County Archives - Toluca County Mining Museum - Toluca County Orphanage - Toluca Lake|
|The Brethren - Monster - Flashlight - Manifestation - Otherworld - Fog World - Real World - Siren - Great Knife - Welcome Sign - Brethren Symbol|