There is a safe on the shelf which contains the "My Flying Lizard" memento. There is also a toy train, which must be turned on to get the key to unlock the front door of the store. The train track must be switched, then when the train is turned on, the train wrecks and Harry retrieves the key.
The toy store has many other toys and posters in it, including a doll holding its own head, a doll house, and a poster for a toy car recall with a phone number that the player can call.
The doll house that can be found in the store very closely resembles the house on Levin Street, and will even have the same colors the player has chosen in the second psychiatric test.