The comic starts off Anne's journey through Silent Hill, set after the bus crash and after her fall into the deep ravine where she encounters Murphy.
As she was about to fall from the tear of a mountain, Anne began to think of her memories. At the same time, she sees Murphy Pendleton as a Bogeyman. After she fell, in which she expected her death, she awakes at the bottom of the ravine, where she saw the dead prison bus driver.
The bus driver, M. Koons, thought to be dead, was awakened for a brief amount of time, before he actually died as he tried to approach Anne. That was when she thought to have saw Willis running into a cave. As she went into the cave, she saw a bloody wheelchair, which reminded her memories of her father, Frank Coleridge.
The 'cave' she entered turned out to be a bathroom, in which an opening suddenly appears in front of her. A shower suddenly opens, which showers blood instead of water. As Anne proceeded through the opening, the Wheelman was seen looking at her.
The opening led her to the Devil's Pit, where she saw a man who resembles Murphy beating a man with a stick. She tried to catch him, but it turned out to be Freddie Gates, one of the prisoners that was on the transfer. However, as Freddie tried to kill her with a pistol, a Weeping Bat killed him gruesomely.
J.P. Sater called her to ride on the train to escape from the creature. As she sits, she saw the eight children who died at an accident. She questions Sater if he was the one who caused it, but he insisted that it was a lie. Her vision suddenly became horrific as she hallucinated the children asking Sater for "another ride", other than the Bogeyman and some Tormented Souls. The comic ends with Anne finding herself alone in an empty train after the hallucination, where she saw Murphy wandering around and tried to freeze him.
- The comic confirmed that the choice "Save her" during Murphy's first encounter with Anne was indeed canon.
|IDW Publishing comics|
|Dying Inside||1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5|
|Among the Damned||One-shot issue|
|Paint It Black||One-shot issue|
|The Grinning Man||One-shot issue|
|Hunger||Released on UMD|
|Dead/Alive||1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5|
|Sinner's Reward||1 · 2 · 3 · 4|
|Past Life||1 · 2 · 3 · 4|
|Anne's Story||1 · 2 · 3 · 4|
|Masahiro Ito comics|
|Cage of Cradle||Released in Japan only|
|Double Under Dusk||Released in Japan only|
|White Hunter||Released in Japan only|
|Anne Marie Cunningham - Murphy Pendleton - George Sewell - Frank Coleridge - Bobby Ricks - Howard Blackwood - John P. Sater - M. Koons - Freddie Gates - Mark Cunningham - Leonard B. Trent|
|Bogeyman - Doll - Leonard B. Trent - Nurse - Prisoner Minion - Screamer - Tormented Soul - Weeping Bat - Wheelman|
|Centennial Building - Devil's Pit - Lakeview Hotel - Overlook Penitentiary - Room 302 (South Ashfield Heights) - Ryall State Prison - Silent Hill - Toluca Lake|
|Fog World - Monster - Otherworld - Real World|
|Tom Waltz - IDW Publishing|